...and the pedals you shall NEVER sell are:

[intheair]

Big muff ram's head
Rat
Metal muff
Nova delay
....are mine.

[Not_the_DJ]

Never say never....but...

Red Witch Moon Phaser: I don't actually gig with it, but everytime I play it at home it I fall in love with it again.

EHX Micro Pog: Sold it once, bought it back...never again

MXR Carbon Copy: I'm on my second one of these, I really should keep this one as I know I'd buy another if I sell it

MXR CAE Wah: The perfect wah

Plus my Suhr Jack Rabbit Tremolo and Whirwind Orange Box Phaser, both are perfect at what they do so it never crosses my mind to sell them.

[stickyfiddle]

Rat Best dirtbox there is.
Hotcake Best light drive for strats by a mile
BYOC Wah Most tweakable-but-user-friendly wah I've used

The Liquid Sunshine isn't quite on the list, but I can't bring myself to sell that either.

[frankus]

never say never...

but pedals I really like are the timmy, ana-echo, 69 fuzz (already on my second of them)

[timmyo]

never say never...

That.

I said I'd never sell my RMC Wah but did.
Any my Hardwire CM-2 but did (twice)
And my Xotic BB-MB but put it up for sale.

[darcym]

Klon,
Analogman TS-9
Korg G4
SweetSound Mojo Vibe,
Marshall Blues Breaker
Mentatone Howie
Fuchs cream de la trem
Fuchs Plush drive
Zendrive
original way huge Aquapuss
Hughs and Kettner Rotosphere,
Wampler Ecstsay
Lazy J Cruiser

I know it's a lot but they are awkward to get and I love them, so I'll never sell them, they just sound the best I'm still in the honey moon period with the Jan ray vemuram but I suspect that will join the list.

[springworks]

Hotcake Best light drive for strats by a mile

Interesting, I tend to use mine more as a creamy lead sound, it's really lovely on the neck pickup.

Great pedal!

[octatonic]

Ibanez OT10- I have 3 of the.

Everything else is replaceable.

[Sporky_McGuffin]

Pretty much the contents of my pedalboard, plus the Zoom stompboxes and my DC-2.

[dindude]

Hmmm, as my board has changed 100% (bit by bit) in the last 12 months I would be foolish to commit!, however, I've tried a LOT of delays and the Diamond Memory Lane Jr has the perfect balance of features for me and a gorgeous tone - I can't see it going anywhere soon....EHX Small Stone is the only pedal I have ever re-bought so that may be in there too.